One day I came back from the gym, and my partner took one look at me and said, “You look like you’ve just slayed a dragon.”

I felt like I had, too!

I was following a particularly demanding program at the time. The workouts had been condensed into shorter sessions, but there were more training days each week, and some of those sessions left me absolutely exhausted. There was a certain satisfaction in knowing how hard I’d worked. But along with the physical demand, they took considerable mental energy, and to really give them my all, I needed the rest of my life to be cooperating too.

I’m not one to shy away from a challenge. But I’ve also come to question how often we make things harder than they need to be.

When we set ourselves a new health goal, whether it’s losing weight, getting stronger, improving our fitness, or simply feeling better, we tend to start thinking about everything we could do to achieve it. Exercise more. Walk 10,000 steps a day. Cut out the treats. Stop drinking. Track our food. Get up earlier, and somehow still sleep eight hours. When motivation is high, we might actually do most of it. For a while, anyway.

But what if we’re asking the wrong question? Instead of asking what’s the most we could do to reach our goal, what if we asked, what’s the least we need to do? The least that will actually get us where we want to go.

More isn’t always better

Before that, I’d been through periods where I spent five days a week in the gym for an hour, on top of another hour of exercise each day. That’s a substantial commitment, and the frustrating thing was that I wasn’t getting the results I wanted.

Looking back, I understand why. I could train until the cows came home, but I wasn’t making the dietary changes needed. I was working incredibly hard, just not on the things that would make the biggest difference.

(If that sounds familiar, and you’re putting in the work without seeing the results, I cover the most common reasons progress stalls even when you’re eating healthfully and exercising, and what you can do about them, in the bonus module of my Plant Forward Week program.)

These days, I structure my workouts differently, including a technique called myo-reps. It’s one of several ways to make training more time-efficient, and it won’t suit every exercise or everyone. But my workouts are shorter, I’m enjoying them more, and I’m getting stronger. They’re still challenging in their own way, but knowing I don’t need to walk out of every session feeling as though I’ve battled a dragon to make progress? That’s a pretty good feeling.

What am I not willing to give up?

Recently, I set myself a new body composition goal. I know how to design a program that would get me there faster. I’ve followed demanding programs before, and I have the knowledge to put together another one myself. But I also know what makes me miserable, and I have absolutely no desire to go back there.

Quite frankly, I’d rather stab myself in the eye than spend months on 1,500 calories, drinking protein shakes mixed with water, with no dessert and a social life that consists of watching everyone else have all the fun.

So this time, before deciding what I was going to change, I asked myself a different question. What am I not willing to give up to get where I want to go?

As it turned out, the list was surprisingly long. Desserts made the top of it, of course.

I enjoy my food. I love big, satisfying meals. I’ve always been more interested in discovering the most I can eat while still achieving my goals than seeing how little I can get away with.

I like having sweet treats. I want flexibility around social occasions. And I certainly don’t want to spend my days feeling hungry or deprived.

At the time, I was also dealing with a foot problem that significantly limited how much walking I could comfortably do. And I didn’t want to spend hours every week doing extra exercise simply to speed things up.

I still have old training and nutrition programs saved on my computer that I can barely bring myself to look at. Some have delivered impressive results when followed to the letter. But looking at the training, restriction and mental energy they demanded, I physically shudder. I’ve spent enough of my life in that space.

There was one thing I was willing to change this time, though: my timeframe. I didn’t have a competition or an important deadline. If taking a little longer meant I could enjoy my food, my training and my everyday life along the way, that was a trade-off I was more than happy to make.

So rather than starting with everything I could possibly change, I started with what I wanted to keep. Then I looked at which adjustments would make the biggest difference. If I can achieve my goal while still enjoying dessert, why would I eliminate it? If I can make progress without pushing through foot pain to hit an arbitrary step target, why would I? And if a handful of well-chosen changes will get me there, why automatically make ten?

And it’s working. I’m meeting my targets, and it feels amazing. There’s a particular kind of satisfaction in realising you’re still moving towards something important while enjoying the things you thought you’d have to give up. You don’t have to choose between achieving your goal and enjoying your life along the way.

I’ve been documenting the process as I go, and I’ll be sharing more about it soon.

Know what you’re signing up for

Asking what’s the least you need to do isn’t about finding excuses to avoid what matters. It’s about identifying the changes that will have the greatest impact and questioning whether all the others are necessary.

There are countless health, fitness and weight-loss programs promising results. Some make extraordinary claims, and others are genuinely well-designed approaches that deliver what they promise. But there are two questions we don’t ask often enough before committing to one.

  1. Am I actually willing to do what this program requires of me?
  2. Am I willing to give up what it asks me to give up?

Because there’s always a trade-off. Certain foods, evenings relaxing on the couch, time with family, hours you could spend on other things you value. Even when the changes themselves are beneficial, the time and energy they demand have to come from somewhere. And as I’ve written before, not everything has to be a priority at once.

Then ask yourself how quickly you actually need to get there. With an ambitious goal and a short deadline, you may need bigger changes or some temporary sacrifices, or you may need to reconsider whether that deadline is realistic. With more flexibility in your timeframe, you have more flexibility in how you pursue your goal.

A plan that asks less of you has another advantage: you don’t have to wait for life to be perfectly organised before you begin. How often have you postponed a new program because of a holiday, a birthday, a busy period at work? With silly season just around the corner, plenty of us are already telling ourselves we’ll start in January. But there’s always something else on the horizon. When your plan leaves room for real life, those events don’t have to derail it before you’ve even started.

Sometimes a short, intensive period of effort makes perfect sense, particularly when you’ve got a specific deadline or a serious health issue. And what you do to achieve a goal won’t always be what you need to do to maintain it. The important thing is to know what you’re signing up for, including what happens when that intensive period ends.

This goes well beyond weight loss, too. Imagine being told your blood pressure or cholesterol needs attention. Improving your diet, moving more, managing stress and sleeping better can all help, and addressing several together can be enormously valuable. But does that mean you need to overhaul every meal, start an ambitious exercise program and reorganise your entire routine all at once? Not necessarily.

The goal isn’t simply to make fewer changes. It’s to make the changes that count.

Finding the changes that make the biggest difference

So how do you put this into practice? I’d start by getting clear on four things:

  • What you want to achieve
  • How quickly you genuinely need to achieve it
  • What you’re willing to change
  • What you’d really prefer to keep

Then look at the changes available to you. Which are likely to make the biggest difference? Which would be relatively easy to accommodate? And which would demand a great deal of effort or sacrifice for comparatively little return?

Perhaps you’ve been considering adding another three hours of exercise a week to support a weight-loss goal. But if your food intake is the main thing holding you back, a few changes to what and how much you’re eating might be a more useful place to start.

Or perhaps an injury, illness, or other circumstances make exercise difficult right now. Depending on your goals, there may still be meaningful improvements you can make through nutrition and other lifestyle changes. You don’t need every lever available to you to start moving in the right direction.

If you’re unsure which changes will make the biggest difference, that’s a good reason to seek professional guidance rather than trying to do everything. Look for someone appropriately qualified who takes the time to understand your goals, circumstances and priorities, rather than handing you a generic set of instructions and expecting you to fit your life around them.

Because knowing what works is only part of the equation. Knowing how to make it work for the person who’s actually going to do it matters too.

Start with enough, then adjust

Once you’ve identified a few changes likely to make a meaningful difference, start there and give them a reasonable opportunity to work. Pay attention to what happens, not just in your results, but in how much time, energy and effort the process is demanding.

One question worth asking about anything already in your routine: if I stopped doing this, would it meaningfully affect my results? If the answer is no, perhaps it doesn’t deserve the time and attention you’re giving it. And before adding anything new, ask whether it’s likely to make a real difference, or whether it’s just one more thing to do.

If you’re progressing towards your goal, enjoying the process and happy with the timeframe, you may not need to add anything else just yet. If you’re not getting the results you want, you have useful information to work with. Review what’s happening and make another adjustment. I’ve found that treating changes as small experiments, rather than permanent commitments, makes it much easier to try something different and see whether it works.

That doesn’t mean you stop improving. But improvement doesn’t always have to mean doing more. Sometimes it means doing something differently, or getting better at what you’re already doing.

A plan with some breathing room also holds up better when life throws you a curveball. A plan that only works when everything goes perfectly is going to be difficult to live with. It’s worth asking what your approach will look like on a difficult day, not just when you have all the time, energy and motivation in the world.

How much is enough?

I’m a big believer in doing hard things and embracing discomfort, in challenging ourselves, stepping outside our comfort zones and discovering what we’re capable of. Some of the most worthwhile things we do require considerable effort.

But I don’t believe in making things harder than they need to be just for the sake of it.

Sometimes the extra effort and sacrifice are absolutely worth it. You might reach your goal faster, achieve more than you originally set out to, or simply enjoy pushing yourself to see what you’re capable of. But those are choices worth making deliberately, rather than assuming you need to do everything possible to succeed.

You don’t have to slay a dragon every time to get where you’re going.

So, how much do you actually need to do? And is doing more worth what it asks of you?

If you’d like to stay connected

If you’re ready to stop starting over and build habits that actually hold up in real life, I’d love to support you.

I also send a short weekly note via email – a little something for your mindset, your plate, and to think about for the week ahead, along with a short midweek story. If that sounds like your kind of thing, you can sign up here.

Leave a Reply